It is hard to miss the overarching message that “breast is best”. NHS clinics tend to be covered with posters stressing all the wonderful properties and benefits of breastmilk over infant formula. Where does that leave parents who want or need to feed their baby (or babies) with formula milk?
Society seems to see breast or bottle feeding as a choice. This leaves no room for nuance and complexity, and can also feel pretty judgemental. I meet mothers who have never grown breasts, or whose breasts do not produce much milk, those who have had surgery, those with complex medical situations…many of these mothers will never be able to fully breastfeed their babies. There are countless women who lost too much blood during the birth or are on a cocktail of medications that make breastmilk production really challenging. I work with abuse survivors, those with mental health issues, women with chronic fatigue, those struggling with multiple babies. Almost every new mother I see, quite frankly, wants a break sometimes and would love their baby to take a bottle from someone else.
So is formula really bad?
A little bit of science.
Formula milk is life saving and nutritionally complete. Number one formula milks for newborns are highly regulated and safe for nearly all babies. A huge amount of research is undertaken every year to try to make formula as close to breastmilk as possible. It is generally derived from cow or goat milk with added oils, sugars, vitamins and minerals. We know that babies thrive on formula milk, and that they continue to grow and develop normally. However, it would be wrong to suggest that formula is the same as, or just as good, as human milk.
Human milk is a fascinating, dynamic substance that changes with baby’s needs. It actively supports the growing baby’s brain, body and immune system, and contains sugars to feed their colonising gut bacteria. Antibodies and viral fragments prime baby’s immune system and women act as a real time virus checker, passing on protection to their baby if either mother or baby becomes unwell. We know that mothers who breastfeed are slightly less likely to get some forms of breast cancer, and that breastfed babies are less likely to be hospitalised with stomach upsets or respiratory infections. Breastfeeding a baby can feel wonderful, as both mother and baby are filled with hormones that help them to be relaxed and happy. For these reasons, many women choose to offer their baby some breastmilk if they can make it, or even use donor breastmilk, as well as formula if baby needs it.
We know that published research is likely to be biased towards the benefits of breastfeeding. Studies that show the benefits of formula feeding are rarely put into journals. This bias can create unnecessary pressure and stress for formula feeding or mixed feeding families. There have been sibling studies of thousands of families with one breastfed child and one formula fed child, which find very few significant differences between them in long term health outcomes.
Does the choice have to be all or nothing? Can’t I mix breast and bottle?
Yes! It is very often possible to feed your baby with some breastmilk either directly or pumped from the breast, and to top up with donor milk or formula. Some women do some full breastfeeds and some full formula feeds in a day, others start with the breast and then add a bottle top up each time or when baby needs it. There is more information on this cycle of top ups here, and on expressing milk in general here. Some parents worry that their baby will become confused between breast and bottle. There is no firm evidence for this, and you can read more about it here. The majority of babies seem to switch between breast and bottle quite well, and if it works for you then it can be an excellent way forward for many families.
It is important to note that breastfeeding works on supply and demand, so the more milk that is taken from the breast by baby or pump, the more milk will be produced. There is no reason to leave breasts time to “fill up” between feeds. In fact, increasing the length of time between breastfeeds tells the breasts that they are not needed and results in less milk production overall. We know in the first few days and weeks of breastfeeding milk supply can be slightly more fragile and more impacted by additional formula feeds than after about eight weeks.
I get very concerned about families who try to exclusively breastfeed when it is not working for their baby, and their baby is not thriving. In these cases, any sensitive health care professional should be actively encouraging the use of a healthy amount of formula.
Dealing with pressure to breastfeed or guilt about using formula
We live in a culture where mothers are expected to somehow minimise all risks and do their absolute best for their babies at any cost. This means that very often the mothers suffer, in terms of anxiety, depression and constant feelings of guilt. It is important to remember that a mother needs to invest in herself as much as in her baby, so that everyone is OK. Some families are going to work best overall when they use formula milk for their baby, either entirely or in combination with breastmilk. The key message is to feed your baby, enjoy your baby, and try not to let the first get in the way of the second.
If you are struggling with unwanted advice from people around you, other mothers share their hints and tips here.
If you are trying your hardest to breastfeed but find it difficult to make sufficient milk, you might like to click here for a letter to those supporting you, and here for some guidance on the process.
If breastfeeding is hard or hurts or you need some additional support, please do not hesitate to reach out to me, and look at the other articles and videos on this website.
For those selecting bottles and formula milk, there is additional information here. The independent site www.firststepsnutrition.org is highly recommended for evidence based information around formula and weaning babies.